Monday, April 18, 2011

I Will Defeat Your Bullet Points with Other Bullet Points

State's welfare clothing stipend dries up

MLive stalwart SageofthePage's other bete noire is Demon Weed. He speaks of it in florid terms straight out of Reefer Madness. I would prefer he stick to ranting about how marijuana causes spontaneous psychotic breaks, rather than attempting to muster truth-y sounding "facts" and "statistics."


First: semantically, it's not clear whether Sage is referring to pregnant black women or their presumed-but-not-necessarily-black female fetuses. His capitalization of the word "Abortion" makes me wonder if he isn't referring to a fearsome Abortion Monster that haunts predominantly black communities, looking for tasty victims. For actual abortion statistics that were not pulled out of someone's ass, try the Guttmacher Institute.

Second: since when is diabetes treatment a bad thing? Naturally it would be better to prevent the onset of Type 2 diabetes, or address it with lifestyle change instead of drugs or insulin, but Type 1 diabetes is not preventable. If liberals hate black people, why do liberal municipal governments fund life-saving medical care? And how can Sage be sure that every single diabetic in New York City who receives subsidized medical care is black?

Third: in the United States, the first minimum wage law was the Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938. I need not remind Sage that prior to the 1930s social conditions vis-a-vis the black community were rather different than they are today. It's as if he's pining for the early 20th-century heyday of sharecropping, which amounted to debt peonage enforced by occasional terrorist attacks.

This proves that...okay, I have no idea. You win, Sage. I can't tell who is supposed to be hating whom anymore. Also note the substance of the actual article, which describes how state welfare benefits will no longer include a clothing allowance of a princely $79 per child, per year. Ultimately Sage is ranting about the possibility of poor kids wearing new socks and sweaters, instead of other kids' castoffs or items from a clothing drive. How can you be against new socks?

No comments:

Post a Comment